Milk Paint vs. Chalk Paint for Cabinets: Which is Better?

Painting your kitchen cabinets is more than just a decorative choice, it’s a protective measure for the wood and an opportunity to add personality and charm to your kitchen.

If you’re looking to give your kitchen cabinets a fresh new look, you might be wondering whether milk paint or chalk paint is the better choice.

Milk paint and chalk paint are both decorative finishes used for furniture, including kitchen cabinets. The main difference lies in their composition and application.

milk paint vs chalk paint for cabinets

Both of these paints have their own unique qualities, and in this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.

Using Milk Paint for Cabinets

Let’s start with milk paint, one of the oldest types of paint on earth. Derived from milk casein and calcium carbonate as its base constituent, milk paint is a natural and eco-friendly option. It’s non-toxic and odor-free, making it a safe choice for your kitchen cabinets, especially if you plan to store perishable food items.

Milk paint usually comes in a powdered form and requires mixing with water before application. The resulting paint is lighter in consistency, which means you might need multiple layers for a thicker finish. But fear not, because milk paint allows you to get creative with a wide range of decorative finishes using various pigments.

However, one downside of milk paint is its lumpy consistency, which necessitates power mixing for a smooth and even finish. Additionally, the paint has a relatively short shelf life, so it’s best to mix only what you need for each project. Over time, milk paint can develop a natural antique look, adding character to your kitchen cabinets.

Pros of Milk Paint

  • You can create unique custom finishes by layering different coats.
  • Eco-friendly and non-toxic, making it safe for kitchen cabinets.
  • Leaves a clear matte finish after waxing.
  • Biodegradable and can be disposed of anywhere.
  • Allows for the creation of unique colors and textures.
  • Adds a native sheen and an antique look over time.

Cons of Milk Paint

  1. Requires power mixing due to its lumpy consistency.
  2. Must be mixed when fresh due to its organic content.
  3. Relatively short shelf life and can’t be stored for too long.
  4. The paint might go bad over time when exposed to moisture and air, leading to biodegradation.
  5. The powdered form of the paint can crack over time unless a bonding agent is applied.
  6. Brush strokes may be visible due to the thinner coats.

Using Chalk Paint for Cabinets

On the other hand, we have chalk paint, known for its thick texture and chalk-like appearance, providing a vintage, matte, and antique finish to surfaces. Chalk paint contains ingredients such as calcium carbonate, chalk pigments, and talc. It was popularized by Annie Sloan in 1990, and since then, various brands have emerged in the market.

Chalk paint comes in a pre-mixed liquid form, saving you the trouble of mixing before use. It only requires hand-stirring, making it a convenient option for many DIY enthusiasts. This paint can be used for both antiquing finishes and modern, smooth textures achieved by sanding down multiple layers.

Unlike milk paint, chalk paint doesn’t reveal brush strokes, giving you a clean and polished look. It dries quickly, usually within an hour or less, and is completely odor-free. However, the high build of chalk paint might make it difficult to feel the underlying texture, but you can always thin it out if necessary.

While chalk paint comes in a variety of attractive colors, creating custom colors can be challenging and might require mixing one chalk paint with another. It’s important to note that some brands of chalk paint might contain toxic ingredients that are harmful to the environment.

Pros of Chalk Paint

  1. Requires only hand-mixing before use.
  2. Can create smooth and modern textures with sanding.
  3. Completely odor-free and dries quickly.
  4. Easy to apply as it comes pre-mixed and ready to use.
  5. Provides strong adhesion on furniture surfaces.
  6. Requires fewer layers for a thick finish.
  7. Does not need priming or a primer.
  8. Longer shelf-life and withstands weather elements.
  9. Allows you to mix different colors for customized finishes.

Cons of Chalk Paint

  1. Higher build can obscure the underlying texture.
  2. Customizing colors might be challenging.
  3. Some brands contain toxic ingredients harmful to the environment.
  4. Requires a top coat (wax or varnish) for better durability.
  5. Generally costlier than milk paint.
  6. The paint can crack over time unless a top coat is applied.

What They Have in Common

Both milk paint and chalk paint have their uniqueness, yet they share similarities.

  1. Both are suitable for furniture, cabinets, doors, and windows.
  2. Both offer a matte finish.
  3. They emit low volatile organic compounds, drying fast.
  4. They comprised of mineral matter like calcium carbonate.

Differences Between Milk Paint and Chalk Paint

1. Composition

Milk paint is an organic mixture that consists of milk protein (casein), lime, and natural pigments. Because of its natural ingredients, milk paint is known for its eco-friendliness and is biodegradable.

In contrast, chalk paint is typically composed of latex paint with additional elements such as calcium carbonate or plaster of Paris. Though many brands attempt to produce eco-friendly versions, the composition can sometimes include substances less natural than milk paint’s ingredients.

2. Preparation

Milk paint is often sold in a powdered form, milk paint must be mixed with water before use. The consistency can be challenging to achieve without power mixing, and lumps must be carefully removed to ensure a smooth finish.

Chalk paint comes ready-to-use, only requiring a gentle hand-mixing. The preparation is more straightforward than milk paint, making it more user-friendly, particularly for those new to painting.

3. Application

Milk paint usually requires multiple thin layers to reach the desired opacity and finish. It has a tendency to absorb into the wood, which can give it a beautiful, authentic look but may require more effort and care in application.

Chalk Paint is known for its thick and forgiving application, chalk paint often requires fewer coats than milk paint. It can create a textured appearance more quickly, but this thickness can sometimes obscure the wood’s natural grain.

4. Shelf Life

In its powdered form, milk paint can be stored for a long time, but once mixed with water, it has a short shelf life and must be used quickly. This can lead to wastage if not carefully planned.

Chalk paint typically has a longer shelf life even after opening, making it more practical for projects that might span over several days or even weeks.

5. Cost

Generally, milk paint is more cost-effective, making it a suitable choice for larger projects or for those on a budget.

While it offers some convenience and unique characteristics, chalk paint is typically more expensive than milk paint, which could be a consideration depending on your project’s scale and budget.

Is Milk Paint or Chalk Paint Better for Kitchen Cabinets?

To choose the best paint for your kitchen cabinets, consider the application scenario. Chalk paint is ideal for fresh or newly made cabinets, as it provides a thick finish and has a firm grip on wood surfaces without the need for a bonding agent. However, it requires a top coat to prevent cracking over time.

On the other hand, milk paint is more suitable for cabinets with existing primer coats. It’s lighter and less prone to cracking when mixed with a bonding agent. Both paints can be sealed with wax or varnish for a long-lasting and waterproof finish.

Ultimately, the choice between milk paint and chalk paint depends on the specific needs of your kitchen cabinets. If you’re seeking a cost-effective, eco-friendly option with a natural antique look, milk paint might be the way to go. Alternatively, if you want a versatile paint that works on various surfaces and dries quickly, chalk paint is an excellent choice.

Whichever paint you choose, remember that painting your kitchen cabinets is an exciting and creative process. Let your imagination run wild and turn those cabinets into stunning pieces that will be the envy of everyone who steps into your kitchen.

If you have any questions or would like to share your experiences with milk paint or chalk paint, feel free to leave a comment below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *